My First Cream Pie 23

Gwen is dangerously close to the deadline and she still needs to sell so many cookies. Luckily, she knocks on the door of a man who's willing to buy all her sweets if she's willing to share all her treats! Kenna and her girlfriends have made a pact to get pregnant at the same time. She lures her newly divorced next door neighbor over to get him to fill her wet pussy with his warm seed! Lily finds out she's pregnant, and goes to her dad's friend for some advice. He tells her how inappropriate it is for them to have this discussion, but when he caught Lily naked in his bed, he changes his mind! Natalia wants to get an invitation to a fraternity party so she offers to tutor the head of the frat. He declines, but when Natalia offers something every young man wants, he eagerly accepts.

Directed by —, My First Cream Pie 23 leans on a strong ensemble — Gwen Vicious, Kenna James, Lily Larimar — to carry a story that balances spectacle with character.

The film landed with audiences for its craft and performances, and remains one of the most talked-about screen titles of 2023.