My First Cream Pie 25

Haley needs to get her grades up or she'll be kicked off the cheerleading squad. Her tutor can't stop thinking about her tight little body. Will she give him the ultimate reward for helping her? Olivia is struggling to understand her sex ed material. Her stepbrother attempts to explain it to her, but when she still is lost, she suggests he demonstrates... When Mickey hears that her stepdad will soon be making a lot of money, her ambitious side kicks in. She starts making it very obvious that she's down to give her stepdad whatever he wants. Madi spills a popsicle on her shirt during a study date. She takes off her top but her goody-two-shoes study partner demands she stop. She notices his boner and forgets all about studying.

Directed by —, My First Cream Pie 25 leans on a strong ensemble — Haley Spades, Madi Collins, Mickey Violet — to carry a story that balances spectacle with character.

The film landed with audiences for its craft and performances, and remains one of the most talked-about screen titles of 2024.