Inspired by the alarming increase in real-life tragedies involving high school bullying and suicide, Teens Like Phil tells the story of a gay teen, Phil, and his former friend, Adam, who brutally bullies him.

A young boy takes on chores and small jobs around his neighborhood to raise money for a ticket to a magic show; but when his grandmother loses her job, he is faced with a difficult decision.

The Youth Group is putting on a show called "The Bibleman Show", but doesn't feel confident that their performance is good enough. Bibleman arrives and encourages the kids by telling them about a time he fought the villain Dr. Decepto, and how he relied on God to get him out of the situation. He encourages the kids to rely on God to make their performance go well, which they do. The audience arrives and the show goes very well, with the Youth Group performing four songs along with a special message spoken by Bibleman.

Bibleman's neighborhood friends invite him to come along as they bring the dynamic Bibleman Show to the entire school. Then join Bibleman as he challenges the malevolent Madame Glitz. Will she keep him captive? Will he break free from Madame Glitz's evil Snare? Stay tuned to find out!