Gracie runs around the small social world of Baltimore. Joined by her best friend Melanie who has a boyfriend she's never met and her bisexual coworker Bentley who's eyeing the recent transplant Andrew, she looks for love in all the wrong places.

When a grave robber tries to barter with a strange antiques dealer, the two trade stories rather than goods. Tales of zombies, vampires, and ghosts are told upstairs while an unspeakable horror waits in the basement.